Arbitration clauses have become a fixture in commercial agreements and commercial loan documents are no exception. The appeal is easy to see: a retired judge with years of experience on the bench, a private forum, and a faster path to resolution than a crowded state or federal court docket. For a lender trying to recover on a defaulted loan, speed matters. But that speed comes at a cost, and in smaller-dollar commercial lending disputes, arbitration fees can significantly erode the very recovery the bank is trying to protect. Before including or invoking an arbitration clause, banks should consider whether the speed of the process justifies the expense.
Are Arbitration Clauses Cost Effective for Commercial Loan Disputes?
A recent arbitration involving a $61,000 breach of contract claim illustrates the point. A bank might pursue this amount against a small business borrower or guarantor after a default on a line of credit or equipment loan. The case reached a final award in 10 months. Had it been filed in court, it is highly unlikely it would have concluded within 10 months after written and oral discovery and a trial. But the parties collectively paid approximately $42,000 in arbitration and arbitrator fees, not including attorneys’ fees.
Put in lending terms, one party’s forum costs alone exceeded a third of the balance in dispute. But state court judges are paid by the government, and the parties pay only filing fees to get the case in front of a judge. For commercial bankers, this math deserves attention at the documentation stage, not after a default.
What Commercial Banks Should Consider Before Requiring Arbitration
Before including an arbitration clause in a loan document, there are a few points to consider:
- Loan size matters. On large credits, arbitration fees may be a modest fraction of the exposure. On smaller commercial loans, lines of credit, and guaranties, those fees can consume a meaningful share of what the bank hopes to recover.
- Fee-shifting provisions are not a cure-all. Most loan documents allow the lender to recover its attorneys’ fees and costs from the borrower. But an award against a borrower already in default is only as good as the borrower’s ability to pay. The bank pays arbitration fees in real dollars now; the reimbursement may never come.
- Uncontested collections cost more in arbitration. Some collection matters are never seriously defended. In court, an unanswered complaint can lead to a default judgment at relatively little expense. In arbitration, the bank will generally still incur filing and arbitrator fees to obtain an award, and that award must then be confirmed in court before it can be enforced.
- There are alternatives. A jury trial waiver, where enforceable, addresses one of lenders’ primary concerns with litigation—an unpredictable jury—while preserving the cost advantages of the courthouse. Some lenders also draft arbitration provisions that are elective, giving the bank the option to arbitrate a particular dispute rather than requiring it.
- The clause is not set in stone. Even when a loan agreement contains a binding arbitration clause, the parties can still agree, after a dispute arises, not to arbitrate and to try the case in state or federal court instead.
Arbitration and mediation clauses have a place in commercial lending and in the right case they can deliver a quick and final result. Before an arbitration clause goes into the bank’s documents—or before the bank invokes one after a default—it is worth asking whether the speed of the award is worth the price. Sometimes, speed and efficiency are not worth the cost. Time is money, or in this case, less time is more money.
- Partner
Mike, managing partner of the Crystal Lake office, is the attorney to call for banks across the Midwest. He has extensive experience representing banks in various types of litigation, including but not limited to: uniform ...
Welcome to Banking Brief: Financial Services Insights, where Amundsen Davis attorneys provide actionable insights on the laws and trends impacting financial institutions and the banking industry.
RSS Feed
